Claims & sources
ISSB / TCFD
Claims & sources for ISSB / TCFD. Every fact below is a verbatim quote from a real document we have stored. ↩ See the full Record
| Claim | Asserted by | Stance | Evidence balance | Source | Receipt |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Carney claimed establishment of TCFD | unattributed | critical | — | Mark Carney and the Question of Authorsh | ↗ |
| Carney's contribution at TCFD was institutional | Mark Carney | pro | — | Introduction: The Pattern in Brief | ↗ |
| carbon pricing is presented as one of the two foundational solutions to climate change | unattributed | pro | — | Forensic Research Memo: Mark Carney's Pu | ↗ |
| shareholders should be able to veto management plans not aligned with net zero by 2050 | unattributed | pro | — | Forensic Research Memo: Mark Carney's Pu | ↗ |
| Net-zero finance is a financial product sold to resolve climate anxiety | McLuhan | critical | — | Research Brief: A McLuhanesque Critique | ↗ |
| TCFD framework leads to mostly non-committal and cherry-picked disclosures | Bingler, Kraus, Leippold and Webersinke | critical | — | Title and Executive Summary | |
| TCFD framework leads to procedural rather than substantive progress | Cojoianu et al. | critical | — | Title and Executive Summary | ↗ |
| TCFD-member lenders' borrowers reduce pollution somewhat | Yu et al. | pro | — | Title and Executive Summary | ↗ |
| TCFD frames climate as a financial risk | unattributed | neutral | — | Research Brief: A McLuhanesque Critique | ↗ |
| The divestment fallacy is that divestment does not change anything in the world | unattributed | critical | — | Title and Executive Summary | ↗ |
| Green bonds may not create much positive environmental impact | unattributed | critical | — | Title and Executive Summary | ↗ |
| TCFD/GFANZ/ESG complex functions as an aura over continued extraction | unattributed | critical | — | Research Brief: A McLuhanesque Critique | |
| The TCFD/GFANZ/voluntary-carbon-market architecture is not keeping up with what's needed to address the ever-growing impacts | Piers Forster | critical | — | Title and Executive Summary | ↗ |
| Bingler et al.'s 'cheap talk' finding on TCFD is methodologically contested by Yu et al. (2025) | Yu et al. | critical | — | Title and Executive Summary | |
| disclosure will drive capital reallocation | unattributed | pro | -1.0 | The Net-Zero / Carbon-Credit / Climate-F |